The Rising of The Shield Hero: A Controversial Isekai Series
Explore the controversial elements and lackluster storytelling of The Rising of The Shield Hero, an isekai anime series. Discover the high production values and impressive animation, but consider the problematic plot and lack of originality. Find out why this series may struggle to gain widespread appeal.
The Controversial Premise of The Rising of The Shield Hero
The Rising of The Shield Hero is an isekai anime series that has garnered controversy due to certain elements of its premise. The first episode introduces Naofumi Iwatani, an average college student who is suddenly summoned to another world along with three other guys. Their mission is to save the world from destructive events known as ‘Waves.’
( Credit to: Animenewsnetwork )
However, controversy arises when Naofumi realizes that he is being treated differently from the other heroes and is unjustly framed for assault by a woman named Myne. The controversy surrounding the series stems from the false rape accusation against Naofumi, which is both ethically questionable and a lazy storytelling device.
This plot element perpetuates harmful stereotypes and creates a narrative that men are victims of a matriarchal conspiracy. Such a portrayal ignores the reality that false rape accusations are rare, and the majority of victims face disbelief and further mistreatment when reporting sexual violence.
Lackluster Storytelling and Unimpressive Protagonist
Aside from the controversy, the premiere episode of The Rising of The Shield Hero fails to impress in terms of storytelling. Naofumi, the protagonist, is uninteresting and lacks depth, making it difficult for viewers to connect with him. Additionally, the world he is transported to lacks originality and relies heavily on generic fantasy MMO tropes.
The conflict revolving around Naofumi’s resentment for being the Shield Hero feels contrived and does not justify the extended runtime of the episode. This lackluster storytelling hinders the series from offering anything unique or engaging to its audience.
High Production Values and Impressive Animation
Despite its flaws in storytelling, The Rising of The Shield Hero does boast high production values. The animation by Kinema Citrus brings the fantasy world to life with vibrant visuals and fluid movements. The attention to detail in the animation is commendable, adding depth and immersion to the series.
In addition to the animation, the score by Kevin Penkin is a standout. The music enhances the atmosphere of the series, creating emotional resonance and capturing the essence of each scene. These high production values contribute to the overall appeal of The Rising of The Shield Hero.
A Difficult Series to Recommend
In conclusion, The Rising of The Shield Hero’s controversial premise and lackluster storytelling make it a difficult series to recommend. While the high production values and impressive animation add some redeeming qualities, they cannot compensate for the problematic elements of the plot.
The isekai genre has become oversaturated, and this series fails to offer anything unique or engaging to stand out from the crowd. Unless significant improvements are made in terms of storytelling and originality, it is difficult to see The Rising of The Shield Hero gaining widespread appeal.
